English 9
Mr. H. Salsich
November 30
Mending A Man:
An Essay On A Tale Of Two Cities' Sydney Carton
Opening Paragraph:
SD: in TTC, Carton is a portrayed as a depressed man
Comment on Hook: alcoholic who pines away for Lucie, who is married
Comment on Hook: he is a self pitying man who believe that no on cares for him
CS: Carton seems beyond repair, but there might still be hope for him
bell word: pity
First Body Paragraph:
echo words: commiseration, compassion
TS: Sydney Carton is a depressed, drunk man
SD: Carton feels like he is a "useless piece of furniture, tolerated for its old service, and taken no notice of.", but nobody actually thinks that
CM: no one actually dislikes Carton as much as he thinks people do, he is just has so much self commiseration
CM: he is just feeling sorrowful for himself for no reason, because his life isn't actually that bad
SD: he believes that no body likes him because he always put second by Stryver
CM: Stryver "shoulders his way through life" while Carton, who "would never be a lion", trails not far behind
CM put down everyday by Stryer who believes that "[his] way is, and always was, a lame way."
SD: Carton is also depressed because the girl he pines for, Lucie is also loved by Stryver
CM: even though Carton professed his love for her first, Stryver still tries to steel her from Carton
CM: Stryver goes as far as talking to Mr. Lorry about marrying
CS: I think that Stryver is the reason that Carton has so much self compassion and feels as if "[...] no man of earth cares for [him]"
Second Body Paragraph:
bell words: condolence, sorrow
TS: Carton seems beyond repair, drowned in his own self condolence, but I have faith that I could help him through his depression
SD: I would tell him that he cannot dwell on the past
CM: he is still in love with Lucie even though she does not love him back and she is happily married
CM: dwelling on things that happened long ago makes it difficult for him to move forward
SD: I would also tell him that alcohol is not the solution to his pain
CM: drinking bumper after bumper is not good, after making you feel better for a short period of time, it makes you feel even worse
CM: getting drunk every time he encounters a problem is a recipe for disaster
SD: lastly, I would tell him to be rid himself of negative influences, such as Stryver
CM: Stryver is always putting him down and putting him second, he does not feel sorrowful for Carton if he has a problem, nor does he help him through it
CM: you should never tolerate being put second by the people that you put first
CS: by taking my advice, I believe Carton could turn his life around
Concluding Paragraph:
echo word: sympathy
SD: Carton, a depressed alcoholic, could turn his life around
Comment on Hook: he could strip himself of his sympathy by getting over Lucie, and no longer tolerating Stryver's harsh words
Comment on Hook: his life doesn't have to be that way
CS: miserable, intoxicated Carton could have a better life
Simone
English 9
Mr. H. Salsich
December 5
TS In the book A Tale of Two Cities, Sydney Carton is portrayed as a depressed man. SD He is an alcoholic pining only for Lucie, who is happily married to Charles Darnay, Carton's peer. CM He is a self-pitying man who believes that no man cares for him. CS Carton seems beyond repair, but I think there might still be hope for him.
TS Sydney Carton is a pitiful and sorry and sad and depressed drunk (polysyndeton). SD He thinks that he is a "useless piece of furniture, tolerated for its old service, and taken no notice of", but nobody actually thinks that of him. CM No one in the book actually dislikes Carton as much as he surmises (F.A.S.T.), he just has so much self commiseration that he feels like people don't want him around. CM He is just feeling sorrowful for himself for no reason because if he opened his eyes, his life isn't actually that bad. SD He believes that nobody likes him because he is always put second by Stryver. CM Stryver "shoulders his way through life" while Carton, who "would never be a lion", trails not far behind. CM He is put down day after day by damaging (alliteration) Stryer who believes that "[his] way is, and always was, a lame way." SD Sydney is also disconsolate (F.A.S.T) because the girl he pines for, Lucie, is also loved by Stryver. CM Even though Carton professed his passion for her primarily (alliteration), Stryver still tries to steel her from Carton. CM Mr. Stryver even goes to Tellson's, a place of sheer business, a place where the people are prim and the atmosphere is proper, to speak to Mr. Lorry about marrying her. (appositive) CS I believe that Mr. Strvyer, who is supposed to be Carton's friend, is the reason why Sydney feels so much self compassion and feels as if "[...] no man on earth cares for [him]".
TS Carton seems beyond repair, drowned in his own self condolence, but I have faith that I could help him through his depression. SD The first thing I would tell him to do to jump start his journey (alliteration) to convalescence (F.A.S.T) would be that he cannot dwell on the past. CM He is still in love with Lucie even though she does not love him back and she is gaily (F.A.S.T) married. CM Dwelling on things that have come and gone makes it hard for people to move forward. SD I would also tell him that alcohol is not the solution to his problems. CM Drinking bumper after bumper is bad (alliteration), after making you feel better for a short period of time, it makes you feel even worse than when you did when you started drinking. CM Carton just gives up and gets drunk every time he encounters a problem, and that is a recipe for disaster, always giving up, never trying to solve the complication, making his body more tolerant to alcohol, allowing him to drink more and more, as if he were a bottomless pit (coordinate cumulative sentence with a simile) . SD Lastly, I would tell Sydney to be rid himself of negative influences, such as his "friend" Stryver. CM Stryver is always putting him down and putting him second, he does not feel sorrowful for Carton if he has a problem, nor does he help him through it. CM He should never tolerate being put second by the people that he puts first, and he should never tolerate being laughed at and teased and insulted and made fun of. (polysyndeton) CS By taking my advice, I believe Carton could really turn his life around.
TS Carton, a depressed alcoholic, could possibly turn his life around. SD His life doesn't have to be the way it is now. CM He could strip himself of his self-sympathy by getting over Lucie, and no longer tolerating Stryver's harsh words. CS Miserable, intoxicated Carton could have a better life.
SELF-ASSESSMENT:
1) A strong point in my essay is the my second body paragraph. I think that the requirements flowed well within the sentences.
2) I would say a weak point in my essay is my first body paragraph. I think some of the sentences are not coherent with each other.
3) I still need to work on my punctuation and making sure that I do not have comma splices within sentences.
4) I would give myself a B+ on this essay.